Tubs vs. Showers: Steve and Erin’s Bathroom Battle
When it comes to home renovations, the decisions can get pretty intense. For Steve and his wife Erin, the big debate wasn’t about countertops or paint colours—it was all about the bathroom. Specifically: Do modern homes really need a bathtub, or are showers enough these days?
This wasn’t just a personal preference. It’s the kind of question that can impact your home’s functionality and appeal to future buyers. Let’s dive into Steve and Erin’s story and what it could mean for your next renovation.
Steve’s Case: Showers Are More Than Enough
Steve is Team Shower all the way. “I don’t think in today’s day and age people are taking baths as much anymore—even kids!” he said. For him, showers are quick, practical, and fit perfectly into busy lifestyles.
And he’s not wrong. Sleek, walk-in showers are trending, especially among first-time homebuyers and families who want convenience over everything else.
If you’re renovating, Steve’s argument is worth considering: Is adding a tub worth the cost and space if showers are what most people prefer?
View this post on Instagram
Erin’s Argument: The Case for the Tub
Erin had a different vision. For her, a bathtub isn’t just functional—it’s a luxury. It’s the ultimate space for relaxation, whether you’re soaking in bubbles or enjoying a little me-time.
Plus, tubs aren’t just about you—they can make your home more versatile for families. Parents with young kids often see bathtubs as a must-have, and for anyone who dreams of a spa-like retreat, a freestanding tub can make all the difference.
In the end, Erin’s vision won, and now one of their bathrooms features a gorgeous tub. Steve, still a proud member of Team Shower, admits the tub does bring a certain charm to their home.
Does Your Home Really Need a Tub?
Whether you’re renovating for yourself or thinking about resale value, this is a question worth asking. Homes with both a walk-in shower and at least one bathtub tend to appeal to a wider range of buyers—and let’s face it, having options is always a win.
Here’s why:
For Families: Bathtubs are practical and often essential for parents with little ones.
Luxury Appeal: A stylish tub can create that spa-like vibe people love.
Resale Value: If you ever sell, having both a tub and a shower could give you an edge.
What’s Your Take: Team Tub or Team Shower?
So, where do you stand? Are bathtubs still a must-have, or do showers tick all the boxes? Whether you’re planning a reno or just dreaming about your ideal home, this debate is one that always sparks strong opinions.
Drop your thoughts in the comments—are you Team Tub or Team Shower?
And hey, if you’re looking to buy or sell a home or need advice on reno decisions that make sense for the market, Steve and the team are here to help. Reach out anytime—we’d love to chat about what’s next for you and your home!
